Social Media Content That Converts: What to Post (and Why It Matters)

If you’ve ever stared at a blinking cursor while trying to figure out what to post on Instagram, you’re not alone. A lot of businesses treat social media like a digital bulletin board. Random updates, recycled content, and sales pitches. The result? Flat engagement, no leads, and a whole lot of frustration.

Here’s the truth: If you want your social media to work, your content needs a strategy. It needs to connect, educate, build trust, and ultimately convert followers into clients or customers. So let’s break down how to move beyond random posting and start creating content that matters.

Why Intentional Content Matters

Let’s get one thing straight: Posting for the sake of posting is not a strategy. Every post should serve a purpose, even if it’s simply reinforcing brand awareness or adding value to your audience’s day. If your content doesn’t align with your goals or speak directly to your ideal client, you’re leaving money on the table.

The algorithm rewards consistency and quality. Your audience does, too.

5 Types of Content That Convert

Here’s what your content mix should include if you want to stop posting aimlessly and start seeing results:

1. Educational Content

Teach your audience something. Whether it’s a quick tip, how-to, or industry insight, this kind of content builds credibility and positions you as an expert.

Examples:

• “5 Signs Your Home’s Siding Needs to Be Replaced (Before It Causes Bigger Problems)

• “What Really Happens During a Roof Inspection”

Red Ball tip: Educational content is perfect for carousels, short-form videos (Reels/TikToks), and blog links

2. Behind-the-Scenes Content

People buy from people. Show them what goes into your work — your process, your team, your workspace. This humanizes your brand and builds trust.

Examples:

• Time-lapse of your crew setting up at a job site

• Photo of a “tool of the week”

3. Value-Driven Posts

Give away free value without expecting anything in return. This could be a checklist, downloadable guide, or even a myth-busting graphic. Make your audience feel like they got something from you.

Examples:

• “Free Exterior Inspection Checklist”

• “Top 5 Tools Every Contractor Should Be Using”

4. Client Success & Testimonials

Social proof is powerful. Let your results do the talking by sharing real stories from your clients or customers.

Examples:

• A carousel showing before/after results from a client

• A video testimonial paired with a caption explaining the project

5. Calls to Action (CTAs)

Don’t be afraid to ask for the next step. Whether it’s booking a consultation, downloading a freebie, or signing up for your newsletter, a strong CTA drives conversions.

Examples:

• “Not sure if it’s time for a repair or replacement? Schedule your free inspection today.”

• “Ready to start your project? Get your no-obligation quote now.”

Keep It Consistent, Keep It Aligned

Great content is consistent, intentional, and always aligned with your larger marketing goals. If you’re not sure where to start, use a simple framework like the 80/20 rule: 80% of your posts should provide value or connect with your audience, and 20% can directly promote your services.

Also, don’t be afraid to repurpose! A great blog post (like this one) can turn into a Reel, carousel, email, and infographic.

Need help developing a content strategy that actually converts? That’s what we do.

Final Thoughts

Content isn’t just about filling a lead. It’s about building a brand that people trust, remember, and want to buy from.

Be intentional. Be strategic. And most importantly, be you.

Want regular tips like this delivered straight to your inbox? Subscribe to our mailing list.